The Undesirability of Appeals in the Family Court
Recently, we have had a number of cases where parties have good prospects to appeal, but
Call us on
Call us on
In a recent Full Court decision (October 2017) of Tomaras & Tomaras and Commissioner of Taxation, the Full Court was asked to determine a question stated in relation to proposed Consent Orders that a Husband and Wife had sought by way of property settlement at the end of their marriage.
The Family Court has powers in some circumstances to make Orders that can be said to directly affect a third party creditor. In particular the Court has powers to substitute one spouse to be liable for the other spouse’s debt, provided certain conditions are met under the Act.
In this particular case, the Wife and Husband agreed that the Wife’s debt to the Commissioner of Taxation (some $250,000.00) were passed to the Husband in that he would be substituted for the debt. Proper notice was given to the Commissioner of Taxation who opposed to the making of such an Order.
In dealing with the case stated, the Full Court had to examine whether the Commissioner of Taxation was firstly bound by the relevant provisions of the Family Law Act. This is because there is a presumption that statutory provisions in general terms, do not bind the crown.
The Full Court determined that the Crown presumption did not apply as the Crown could certainly benefit for such provisions (for instance, the substitution of such a debt could allow a more financially wealthy party to assume the debt, rather than an impecunious spouse).
The Full Court also held that the Commissioner of Taxation was a creditor in relation to the third party provisions of the Family Law Act.
Before Husbands and Wives get too excited about substituting the other for their substantial tax debts, one must keep in mind that there are several criteria to be satisfied before any creditor has their debt substituted as part of a matrimonial property settlement.
In particular, the third party cannot have any of its substantive rights or property interest altered under any circumstances. In addition, the third party must be afforded procedural fairness (i.e given sufficient notice about the proposed Order) and further, if it is not foreseeable at the time, that the Order would result in the debt not being paid in full – in other words, if there is any doubt about the debt being paid in full by the substitute party, then the Court would not make the Order.
There was also a legal argument about whether the substituted debtor would assume the rights of the other spouse, under the Income Tax Assessment Act (including rights to objection etc) and whilst that was not determined finally – the Full Court seemed to be of the view that such rights would also pass to the substituted debtor.
The decision is certainly interesting and it is another example of the wide reaching powers of the Family Court in relation to third parties and in particular, third party creditors in relation to matrimonial property settlements.
In this particular case, the Wife and Husband agreed that the Wife’s debt to the Commissioner of Taxation (some $250,000.00) were passed to the Husband in that he would be substituted for the debt. Proper notice was given to the Commissioner of Taxation who opposed to the making of such an Order.
In dealing with the case stated, the Full Court had to examine whether the Commissioner of Taxation was firstly bound by the relevant provisions of the Family Law Act. This is because there is a presumption that statutory provisions in general terms, do not bind the crown.
Recently, we have had a number of cases where parties have good prospects to appeal, but
It is probably commonsense and goes without saying, but in so many matters we have clients
The Family Law Amendment Bill 2023 (Cth) which was passed on 19 October 2023 will result
© 2024 Hartley Family Law – All Rights Reserved | Privacy | Terms & Conditions
The Privacy Statement of the Company is incorporated into these Terms and Conditions. The Company respects the privacy of all its customers and business contacts. The Company is subject to the requirements of the National Privacy Principles which are contained in the Privacy Act.
1. How is personal information collected?
Your name, email address and phone number are collected on the contact form to allow the Company to contact you.
If you email or phone the Company directly, then the Company may record your personal details.
Your personal information may be used to:
a) Improve service to you, the customer
b) The Company may use personal information about you for marketing and research purposes. If you do not wish this to occur, please contact us and we will ensure this does not occur
c) Your personal information is not disclosed to any organisation outside of the Company.
2. Will personal information be given to anyone else?
The Company does not sell or provide your personal information to any other company.
3. Security of personal information
The Company employees are required, as a condition of their employment, to treat personal information held by the Company as confidential, and to maintain the confidentiality of that personal information.
The Company protects the personal information it collects in a secure database.
4. Access and correction
You can access your data at any time by contacting the Company directly.
You also have the right to ask us to correct information about you which is inaccurate, incomplete or out of date.
We ask you to contact the Company by email or phone using the Company contact details if you wish to access or correct any of your personal details.
5. Online privacy issues
To the extent that this Privacy Policy applies to online privacy issues, it is to be read as forming part of the terms of use for our website. When you deal with the Company whether online or otherwise, the Company takes its privacy obligations seriously.
6. Additional privacy information and how to contact the Company
The Company may change its Privacy Policy at any time.
For further information about privacy issues and the protection of privacy visit the Australian Federal Privacy Commissioner’s website at www.privacy.gov.au. If you feel that The Company is not complying with this Privacy Policy, or if you have other privacy concerns, please contact the company.
