Call us on

In Family Court matters, the parties will often engage a Single Expert Forensic Accountant to value a parties business interest as part of the overall identification and valuation of property interests.

Over the years, we have noticed an increasing willingness by forensic valuers to sometimes opine different valuation outcomes and ranges based on different hypotheticals.  In some cases, this may be due to difficulties surrounding the valuation and methodology chosen, or in other cases, there simply being an expression of a range of possible outcomes, rather than an explicit value being chosen.

On the one hand, valuations that offer a range of values or different hypotheticals, can sometimes assist more in mediations or negotiations where parties have room to manoeuvre and try to reach a settlement that meets everyone’s desired outcomes.  However, the danger in having expert evidence provide a range, is that it opens up the Judge’s discretion to choose any value withing that range.  This was highlighted in a Full Court decision in the Family Court in Samper v Samper [2021] FamCAFC 140.

In this matter a Judge simply picked the mid-way point between the range of values that had been offered. 

The Single Expert evidence had been allowed to provide a range and the expert was not questioned or cross-examined at all. 

In this case, the Full Court emphasised the fact that it was simply a matter of discretion and whether or not that decision by the Judge was right or wrong, the fact remained that it was within a range of outcomes suggested by the independent Forensic Accountant and in a situation where both parties had agreed to the expert providing such a range. 

Certainly, if there had been competing or duelling experts who had both proffered a different valuation, then the automatic picking of a halfway point between those valuations could have been subject to a successful appeal.  However, in circumstances where the parties allow such evidence to be admitted, it is very difficult to interfere with a Judges discretion in picking a valuation between that legitimate range. 


If you need any assistance or discussion about your property settlement or valuation matters, please do not hesitate to contact our Brett Hartley or our client services manager, Tyanne Su’A.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


How to choose the right lawyer for you

We Only Send You Awesome Stuff =)

Privacy Policy

The Privacy Statement of the Company is incorporated into these Terms and Conditions. The Company respects the privacy of all its customers and business contacts. The Company is subject to the requirements of the National Privacy Principles which are contained in the Privacy Act.

1. How is personal information collected?
Your name, email address and phone number are collected on the contact form to allow the Company to contact you.
If you email or phone the Company directly, then the Company may record your personal details.
Your personal information may be used to:
a) Improve service to you, the customer
b) The Company may use personal information about you for marketing and research purposes. If you do not wish this to occur, please contact us and we will ensure this does not occur
c) Your personal information is not disclosed to any organisation outside of the Company.

2. Will personal information be given to anyone else?
The Company does not sell or provide your personal information to any other company.

3. Security of personal information
The Company employees are required, as a condition of their employment, to treat personal information held by the Company as confidential, and to maintain the confidentiality of that personal information.
The Company protects the personal information it collects in a secure database.

4. Access and correction
You can access your data at any time by contacting the Company directly.
You also have the right to ask us to correct information about you which is inaccurate, incomplete or out of date.
We ask you to contact the Company by email or phone using the Company contact details if you wish to access or correct any of your personal details.

5. Online privacy issues
To the extent that this Privacy Policy applies to online privacy issues, it is to be read as forming part of the terms of use for our website. When you deal with the Company whether online or otherwise, the Company takes its privacy obligations seriously.

6. Additional privacy information and how to contact the Company
The Company may change its Privacy Policy at any time.

For further information about privacy issues and the protection of privacy visit the Australian Federal Privacy Commissioner’s website at If you feel that The Company is not complying with this Privacy Policy, or if you have other privacy concerns, please contact the company.